1
Best Overall
W&P Peak Silicone Everyday Ice Tray
Credit: W&P
Pros
Dishwasher safe
Includes lid
Durable, but flexible
You can't go wrong with the highly-rated W&P Peak Silicone Everyday Ice Tray, which holds 12 1.25-inch ice cubes. It's made of food grade, BPA-free silicone that wraps a steel frame for durability. The lid prevents spills and helps it stack in the freezer, in addition to keep ice from absorbing odors. Due to its flexibility, you can easily pop out one cube at a time.
2
Best For Sphere Cubes
Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds, Set of 2
Now 10% Off
Credit: TovoloPros
Dishwasher safe
Ice melts slowly
Cons
Only produces two cubes
For stunning cocktails, this set of Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds is the way to go. Each mold produces a 2.5-inch cube that melts slowly. Say goodbye to watered-down drinks! They're also BPA-free and come with lids to keep out funky odors.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3
Best Spill-Free
OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
Credit: OXO
Pros
Dishwasher safe
Includes lid
Hate filling an ice cube tray only to have it spill all over the kitchen? The OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray keeps spills at bay with its silicone lid that seals water into the tray.
It's also great for stacking and protecting ice from freezer odors. And the rounded bottom lets you remove cubes easily.
4
Best Versatile
Souper Cubes Ultimate Set
Credit: Souper Cubes
Pros
Includes lids
Fill lines for easy measuring
Also available individually
Cons
Pricey
While each of these trays are sold individually, the Souper Cubes Ultimate Set comes with all four sizes for freezing anything from ice cubes and coffee to baby food and soup. They're made out of BPA-free food-grade silicone with steel-embedded rims for durability. Plus, they feature fill lines for measuring and lids to keep out odors.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5
Best Set
AiBast Ice Cube Trays
Credit: AiBast
Pros
Variety of ice shapes and sizes
Includes lids
Dishwasher safe
This set of AiBast Ice Cube Trays includes three silicone trays of different shapes and sizes. The large spheres and square cubes are great for cocktails, while the honeycomb cubes add a unique touch to your drink.
"These ice molds seal very well with their silicon lids," said one reviewer. "The silicon makes removal easy."
6How We Picked These Products
When choosing the best ice cube trays, we relied on customer reviews. Removing ice in one piece is key, so we looked for products that make the removal process easy. We also included trays that create different shapes and sizes of ice and ones that include lids to avoid spills and odors.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below