11 Store-Bought Pumpkin Pies That Could Totally Pass As Homemade
Everyone's favorite fall treat — minus all that messy prep.
Delish editors handpick every product we feature. We may earn commission from the links on this page.
Let's be real. In the midst of prepping for a fall feast (Thanksgiving or otherwise), there's a lot to worry about between brining the turkey, peeling potatoes, and chilling the cranberry sauce. So much, in fact, that dessert might even be a bit of an afterthought. To help get dessert on the table faster, we've found some tasty store-bought or mail-order pumpkin pie options that taste just like the real thing. Now dig in!
Sweet Things Pumpkin Pie with Leaf
$50 BUY NOW
Handmade at Sweet Things Bakery in Tiburon, California, this pie is filled with a creamy pumpkin custard spiced with aromatic cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. The crust is perfectly flaky and buttery, and there's even an adorably autumnal pastry leaf for decoration on top. If you're looking for a seriously sweet centerpiece, this pie will be the star of your dessert spread.
More: Everything You Need to Host the Ultimate Thanksgiving Dinner
Southern Baked Pumpkin Pie
$65 BUY NOW
Baked in small batches by the Southern Baked Pumpkin Pie, this gorgeous pie has a signature buttery crust, a warm and spicy aroma, and a deliciously creamy texture. It's shipped frozen, so you can thaw and serve whenever the occasion strikes.
Sara Lee Pumpkin Pie
$6 BUY NOW
Many reviewers agree that both the crumbly crust and the warm fall spice mixture used in this frozen pumpkin pie from Sara Lee tastes so good, your guests might just think it's made from scratch. We won't tell!
Grand Traverse Pie Company Genevieve's Pumpkin Pie With Pecans
$35 BUY NOW
A fall classic with a savory twist, Grand Traverse Pie Company's Genevieve's Pumpkin Pie is topped with toasted pecans for added crunch and nutty goodness.
Little Pie Company Pumpkin Pie
$40 BUY NOW
This pumpkin pie from New York City-based bakery Little Pie Company is moist, flavorful, and an absolute must-have for any harvest dessert spread.
Katz Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pie
$45 for pack of six BUY NOW
This tasty gluten-free pie from Katz is also dairy-, tree nut-, and soy-free, so you can serve it with confidence if you or your guests have food allergies or restrictions. Reviewers especially love this pie's buttery and super flaky crust.
Three Brothers Bakery Pumpkin Cheesecake
$50 BUY NOW
If you're absolutely torn between pumpkin pie and cheesecake, this delicious Pumpkin Cheesecake from Texas-based Three Brothers Bakery will make your dessert decision much easier. Chocolate graham crust adds just the right amount of crunch for a truly satisfying slice.
Grand Traverse Pie Company Northport Pumpkin Pie
$30 BUY NOW
The texture of this rich and creamy American classic has been described by taste-testers as "dense" and "mousse-like." We think it'll quickly become a new tradition at your Thanksgiving dinner table.
Wolferman's Gluten-Free Pumpkin Pie
$35 BUY NOW
Another excellent gluten-free option, this pie is made from wholesome ingredients, including natural pumpkin, ginger, cloves, and cinnamon, proving that adhering to a special diet doesn't mean sacrificing flavor.
Burgers' Smokehouse Pumpkin Pie
$43 BUY NOW
This 10-inch pumpkin pie easily serves six to eight people, and you can store it in the freezer year-round before you're ready to bake it for a special cooler-weather dessert.
Three Brothers Bakery Pumpecapple Piecake
$250 BUY NOW
In case you're trying to impress your in-laws or you're feeding a small army of pumpkin pie lovers, you'll want to invest in this gargantuan Pumpecapple Piecake from Three Brothers Bakery. Called the "Turducken of pie and cake," this megatreat features three different pies enclosed by three layers of cake.
45 Best Packable Beach Food Recipes
8 Things You Should NEVER Keep On Your Kitchen Counter
I Tried Ninja's Outdoor Pizza Oven
I Blind-Tasted 7 Cottage Cheese Brands & The Winner Is Better Than Good Culture
