Skip to Content

Quiz: Can You Tell Which M&M Flavors Are Real?

You're no M&Mateur. Now prove it to the world.

By
M&M's White Cheesecake
Courtesy of Walmart

M&M's has been churning out new flavors every few months, and with each new addition, we have to wonder: Wait, is this real?! In honor of the crazy flavors out there, we Photoshopped a few we wish existed. See if you can separate the real deals from the wannabes.

1

Key Lime Pie

Green, Finger food, Ingredient, Baked goods, Tooth, Dessert, Sweetness, Recipe, Food group, Dairy,

A key lime-flavored white chocolate, studded with graham cracker bits?! Oh. My. Pie.

2

It's FAKE!

Text, Font, Brand, Symbol, Graphics, Coquelicot, Artwork,

But M&M's, we'll totally let you steal that idea.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Pumpkin Spice Latte

Ingredient, Serveware, Animation, Sweetness, Junk food, Finger food, Illustration, Cup, Animated cartoon, Moustache,

Your favorite candy just went full-on basic. We bet Ms. Brown's rocking Uggs here, too. 

4

It's REAL!

Red, Font, Logo, Text, Orange, Brand, Line, Graphics, Graphic design,

C'mon, you know M&M's gotta stay fresh with the trends. It almost gave Starbucks' PSL a run for its money in Fall 2015.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Birthday Cake

Food, Snack, Toy,

Hey, isn't true birthday cake more Funfetti-inspired

6

It's REAL.

Red, Font, Logo, Text, Orange, Brand, Line, Graphics, Graphic design,

M&M's all about that cake, cake, cake, cake, cake. And they took a chocolatier stance on the trend. We don't mind one bit.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Frappuccino

Brown, Font, Animation, Beak, Animated cartoon, Junk food, Graphics, Snack, Confectionery, Finger food,

You voted, M&M's answered. Or did they?

8

It's FAKE!

Text, Font, Brand, Symbol, Graphics, Coquelicot, Artwork,

If the PSL can happen, we're still holding out hope a Frappuccino flavor could happen.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

Café Mocha

Cafe Mocha M&Ms
M&Ms

If you break them open very carefully, you can see leaf-shaped latte art swirled into every chocolate.

10

It's REAL!

Red, Font, Logo, Text, Orange, Brand, Line, Graphics, Graphic design,

Okay, so you won't see a swirl of latte art in the chocolate, but it was a Target-exclusive flavor back in winter 2015.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11

Coffee Nut

Brown, Text, Font, Junk food, Finger food, Serveware, Animation, Graphics, Baked goods, Confectionery,
M&Ms

Wha, wha, waaaait — we've been burned before. Could this be a real, vote-winning M&M flavor?!

12

It's REAL!

Red, Font, Logo, Text, Orange, Brand, Line, Graphics, Graphic design,

Yup, java fanatics — Coffee Nut M&M's do exist, and you can get them in stores everywhere. Sadly, they won't give you the caffeine boost you'd get from a latte, but it does have that fresh-brewed flavor.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13

Pancakes

Food, Ingredient, Cuisine, Finger food, Dish, Breakfast, Baked goods, Junk food, Bun, Snack,

M&M's for breakfast? We could get behind that.

14

It's FAKE!

Red, Orange, Logo, Text, Font, Brand, Graphics, Illustration,

That won't stop us from eating M&M's for breakfast anyway, so who really wins, huh? (Answer: Our dentist.)

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15

Fluffernutter

Junk food, Vegetarian food,

Nostalgia overload! Did M&M really combine your favorite childhood sandwich-masquerading-as-dessert with your favorite actual dessert?!

16

It's FAKE!

Red, Orange, Logo, Text, Font, Brand, Graphics, Illustration,

This is almost as depressing as the day Butterfinger BB's were discontinued

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
17

Easter Sundae

Easter Sundae M&Ms
Walmart

Ah, following that hallowed Easter tradition of ... eating ice cream sundaes in your Sunday best. That's a thing, right? 

18

It's REAL!

Red, Font, Logo, Text, Orange, Brand, Line, Graphics, Graphic design,

It's a thing if you work for M&M's, apparently. They were sold at Walmart last spring.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19

Cookies & Crème

Animation, Ingredient, Finger food, Cuisine, Aqua, Advertising, Animated cartoon, Tooth, Junk food, Baked goods,

If you thought the gooey core in caramel M&M's was groundbreaking, just wait until you try the crunchy cookie center of these bad boys.

20

It's FAKE!

Red, Orange, Logo, Text, Font, Brand, Graphics, Illustration,

Sorry, you might be waiting forever for those; we made up that flavor. If the design looks eerily familiar though, it's because it's inspired by the packaging for M&M's ice cream sandwiches. We're sneaky like that, and we're sorry for so ruthlessly toying with your emotions.

Watch Next 
preview for Watch Our Newest Videos
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below