Skip to Content

These Are The Best Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream Flavors

One flavor clearly reigns supreme.

By
preview for 11 Sweet Things To Know About Ben & Jerry's

Browsing through the freezer aisle of the grocery store is an incredibly personal experience. You stop at the Ben & Jerry's section, of course, and are either someone who goes for the same pint every time or chooses to mix it up every so often. Ben & Jerry's ice creams are expertly made to pack as much flavor and texture into every bite and there's a lot that goes into creating a brand new pint. For those who may not have a go-to, we took it upon ourselves to duke it out amongst the Delish team in order to create a definitive list of our favorite flavors. You don't have to take our word for anything but we're sure you'll love them too...

1

Cherry Garcia

cherry garcia
Ben & Jerry's

The iconic Ben & Jerry's flavor known as Cherry Garcia was actually made because of an anonymous customer suggestion about making a flavor in honor of Grateful Dead's Jerry Garcia. The flavor debuted in 1987 and is one of the brand's top three most popular flavors. Jane Williamson was eventually credited for the original anonymous suggestion and the mix of cherry ice cream, whole cherries, and fudge flakes is available in grocery stores everywhere. As our editorial director put it: "It was a revelation."

2

Americone Dream

americone dream
Ben & Jerry's

Americone Dream, the Stephen Colbert-inspired flavor, includes fudge-covered waffle cones for crunch and caramel swirl for richness all in vanilla ice cream. Sales of this flavor support the Stephen Colbert Americone Dream Fund which benefits disadvantaged children, veteran families, and environmental causes.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Mint Chocolate Cookie

mint chocolate cookie
Ben & Jerry's

For those who like the combination of mint and chocolate, opt for Mint Chocolate Cookie because "it's neither overly minty nor overly cookie-y" according to members of the Delish team. The peppermint ice cream includes chunks of chocolate sandwich cookies rather than plain old choc chips.

4

Half Baked

half baked
Ben & Jerry's

Half Baked is the best of both worlds, with vanilla ice cream, chocolate ice cream, chocolate chip cookie dough, and fudge brownie pieces in every bite. You can never go wrong with it.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Chocolate Fudge Brownie

chocolate fudge brownie
Ben & Jerry's

"It somehow puts three different chocolate textures together and for that I am grateful," said one of our video editors, which is absolutely true. You don't have to stray from the classics sometimes! It includes fudgey brownie pieces throughout chocolate ice cream, and the brownies are made at New York’s Greyston Bakery, where part of their greater-good mission is to provide jobs to low-income city residents.

6

Phish Food

phish food
Ben & Jerry's

You don't have to be a Phish fan to love this flavor but the fish-shaped fudge pieces are a huge selling point. Mix that into chocolate ice cream with marshmallow and caramel swirls, and you have yourself a killer pint. Pretty sure if this flavor could talk it'd say, "You Enjoy Myself" or something like that.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Chunky Monkey

chunky monkey
Ben & Jerry's

Chunky Monkey is often available at local ice cream shops which may be what makes the Ben & Jerry's flavor so nostalgic and delicious. Banana ice cream, fudge chunks, and walnuts...as one editor put it simply: "Hell yes!"

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below