All 40 Of Talenti's Flavors, Ranked

We applaud the biscuit-yness that this flavor attempts, plus the peach flavor is subtle, not overpowering.

The vanilla flavor in this gelato is solid, with ribbons of blueberry throughout. The crumble is so addicting we wish there was even more of it.

We were ready for this flavor to be all about that cookie, and it definitely is. In fact, we wish the cookie pieces were just a little bigger so we could have even more delish crunch.

There were real bits of pistachio in here, and we were seriously impressed.

Those who hate eggnog weren't into this (duh), but those that are fans thought it was a fair replacement during the part of the year when we're wishing it was the holidays.

Talenti knows how to make a delicious chocolate pint, and this one is solid. We just want even more brownie bits, please!

Coconut as the main gelato flavor was a little weird at first, but everyone appreciated the real chunks inside.

Another solid chocolate option, but we wouldn't be mad about even more fudge swirls next time.

You can smell the cinnamon before you taste it, and for our cinnamon lovers that was a very good thing.

The cheesecake flavor is nice, and would be even better adorning an actual cheesecake (so say a bunch of cheesecake-obsessed New Yorkers).

Vanilla bean and dulce de leche sound luxe on their own, and luckily this flavor lives up to it.

Talenti makes another mint flavor (more on that later) that beat out this one in a head-to-head competition ... but the Delish team still scarfed down both.

The house was very split on this one. We had people voting yay — "So good and honey-y!" — and folks who were just a little confused by what they were tasting. Still a super solid flavor.

This pint is definitely on trend, and had its fans, but ultimately our team thought it was a little too sweet to win the battle of Talenti's coffee flavors (see more on that down this list).

Like a grown-up chocolate chip, this flavor is full of toasty, nutty chunks. Amazing with a cup of coffee.

A really good basic, but still not the ultimate Talenti chocolate, in our opinion.

Peanut butter lovers, we have another pick for you further down the list, but the chocolate in this was addictive.

We loved the fruity flavor, and the consistency was creamy, but we wouldn't have been mad if there were more chocolate chips.

Another good staple for when you're craving something classic.

As far as vanilla gelato goes, this is a great option. Most tasters gave to-the-point answers that you couldn't disagree with — "classic", "good", "solid."