We Ate Dozens Of Little Debbie Snacks In One Day—Here Is Our Definitive Ranking

These donuts were too dry for us to even finish. Cute, yes, but they don't make the cut.

This was an extremely polarizing pick among our tasters. Some fell head over heels for the bouncy marshmallow center and the nostalgic banana flavor. Others could barely keep a bite down. If you're among the sick people who actually enjoy eating banana Laffy Taffy, this one's for you.

We spent the entire time eating these wishing that we were eating Cosmic Brownies instead. They're not bad, but why eat them when there's a near perfect alternative offered by the same brand?

The Cherry Fruit Pies get points for the pastry, but the filling doesn't really deliver a cherry flavor. It's more like a generic sweetness.

These donuts, like the other Little Debbie donut options, are on the dry side. But as one taster noted, the sweet, crisp glaze redeems it. You definitely want to dunk these into a cup of coffee.

Not going to lie—many of us were scared to try these Unicorn Cakes. You definitely can't find these colors out in nature. But once you get past the vibrant hues, these cakes taste like strawberry lip gloss in a good way.

Snickerdoodle Creme Pies are a relative newcomer to the Little Debbie lineup. We absolutely loved the cinnamon-sugar crystals that added a surprise burst of crispness in the cookies, but they overall didn't read as snickerdoodles.

Zebra Cakes are one of the more nostalgic offerings in the Little Debbie lineup. And for the most part, the flavor holds up to the test of time. One of our tasters said, "I love how plushy it is."

But we also think our younger selves were easily swayed by the striped design. There are other Little Debbie snacks that probably deserve more hype instead.

The Little Debbie Fudge Rounds are super decadent, so much so that we would struggle to eat an entire one on our own. But if you're looking for an extra indulgent treat it's a solid pick.

Many of us have fond childhood memories of Honey Buns, but did they hold up in the taste test? Yes and no. Some said they were too sweet, but we love them for their soft texture and the mems, of course.

Frosting lovers, rise up! The cookies in this Chocolate Chip Creme Pie are essentially there just to be a vehicle for the rich, vanilla creme in the center.

The Star Crunch Cookies are a serious textural experience. You get the sticky caramel in the center, the melty chocolate, and the crispness of the puffed rice coating. We wouldn't call it a crunch necessarily, but it's still really enjoyable.

These classic cookies weren't quite as we remembered—perhaps a bit too sweet. But regardless, they're still a favorite. "The classic. I'll always love these," wrote a tester. "Sweet, but the oat balances out."

All of the nostalgia of an elementary school birthday party in a mini muffin package.

Imagine if you take a Twinkie, then added a bright pink strawberry jelly in the center. The texture of the Strawberry Shortcake rolls are soft and pillowy, and strikes the right level of sweetness without being excessive.

There's something about a pre-packaged blueberry muffin that evokes a delightful nostalgia. And these mini muffins are no different—they're by far the best mini bite in the Little Debbie lineup.

Chocolate, peanut butter, and crunch—what more could you ask for? While some thought there was too much wafer, others enjoyed this one. "Perfection. Truly," wrote one tester.

We suspect that this is the same jelly that's found in the center of the Strawberry Shortcake Rolls—which is definitely a good thing. The bright, nostalgic artificial fruit flavor pairs perfectly with the crisp cookie, the fluffy creme, and the rich chocolate coating.

We loved the cinnamon and pecan flavor of these, but wish there were more pecans. The outside was a bit dry, but the inside was our favorite part.

What's not to love about the Chocolate Cupcakes? They're creamy, fudgy, rich, and just quintessentially Little Debbie. No notes.