Skip to Content

Delish's 8 Biggest Food Fails of 2015

We prefer the term "teachable moments."

By
Delish's Biggest Cooking Fails
Candace Braun Davison/Joanna Saltz

At Delish, we don't strive for absolute perfection; we just care whether a recipe tastes good. And, like any mere mortals, sometimes the dishes we test wind up wildly different than the vision we had in our heads.

So here, we raise a glass—or perhaps a fistful of Fireball Jell-O—to those moments when your cake is an epic fail, your ice cream cone cupcakes look melted beyond recognition, and your turkey cookies make small children cry. We've been there, and we won't let some Dumpster-worthy dishes keep us from cooking, so don't let it stop you, either.

8. The Time The Freezer Failed Us

Beige, Ivory, Dishware, Peach, Natural material, Paint,
Candace Braun Davison

The night before Kim Tranell came in to show us how to sketch Taylor Swift's face using buttercream frosting, we baked and frosted two cakes, then stuck them in the freezer so they'd be easier to work with the next day. Little did we know that a bottle of chocolate sauce had sprung a leak, causing it to drip all over the dessert.

We're always happy to have spare cake on hand, but never more so than on this day.

7. The Time We Got Impatient

Brown, Food, Sweetness, Red, Vegan nutrition, Natural foods, Fruit, Apple, Ingredient, Peach,
Joanna Saltz

When we first tested topping combinations for this round-up of fun ways to trick out caramel apples, we got a little overzealous and started rolling apples in sprinkles, cake and cookie bits the second they were dipped in boiling-hot caramel sauce.

Lesson learned: Give the caramel sauce a few minutes to cool before dipping, so it's not as runny as water, and stick to lighter toppings. (Pop-Tart chunks slipped right off; crumbled pastries stuck.)

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

6. The Time We Tried to Be Artsy-Cool

Cup, Coffee cup, Serveware, Drinkware, Drink, Teacup, Espresso, Café, Single-origin coffee, Flat white,
Candace Braun Davison

Envious of the latte art that's everywhere on Instagram (seriously, Elsa?!), we ordered a cup to enjoy—and, of course, post. But the end result wound up looking a little too phallic to share. Until now.

5. The Time Our Dessert Dip Turned Lumpy

Food, Cuisine, Finger food, Dessert, Ingredient, Sweetness, Vanilla ice cream, Ice cream, Biscuit, Dairy,
Candace Braun Davison

We've been big fans of dessert dips this year, but that doesn't mean every one we make gets immortalized on Delish. Like this Caramel Apple Cheesecake dip. It had so many things going for it—but no one could get past its cottage cheese-like texture.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

4. The Time We Celebrated Prince George's Birthday

Prince George Cake Fail
Alyssa Fiorentino

Who would've thought that there's a huge difference between watching a skilled buttercream artiste frost a cake and actually doing it yourself?! Oh wait—everyone? Hmm.

I must have missed that memo when I enthusiastically volunteered to recreate Prince George's face in frosting in honor of the regal toddler's birthday. And wound up creating a spot-on Andy Richter/young John McCain/disapproving grandpa cake.

3. The Time We Basically Made Gak on a Stick

Food, Vegetable, Natural foods, Produce, Purple, Ingredient, Black, Violet, Whole food, Snapshot,
Joanna Saltz

Blueberry Cheesecake Popsicles sounded like the most refreshing-yet-decadent treat to kick off summer. Too bad they came out of the freezer—after 14 hours, mind you—looking like the gelatinous Nickelodeon toy from the '90s.

Thankfully, these seven Dixie-Cup pops are basically foolproof.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

2. The Time We Invented a "Chocolate Condom"

Craft, Sweetness, Creative arts, Still life photography, Body jewelry,
Candace Braun Davison

If you leave chocolate-covered frozen bananas out too long, the bananas turn slimy—and slip right out of their chocolate shell, prompting one passerby to pop into our test kitchen and ask, "Hey, is that a chocolate condom?" Um, no. Just ... no.

1. The Time We Created A Cookie ... Monster

Finger food, Food, Chocolate chip cookie, Cookies and crackers, Ingredient, Baked goods, Cookie, Chocolate chip, Dessert, Cuisine,
Candace Braun Davison

Who wouldn't want to eat ice cream out of a chocolate chip cookie bowl?! We'd seen pictures of these beautiful bowls—made from covering the cups of upside-down muffin tins with chocolate chip cookie dough—all over Pinterest, and after trying it out for ourselves, all we can say is, nailed it.

Watch Next 
preview for Watch Our Newest Videos
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below