46Rainbow Swirl
Halo TopWe'll spare you most of the comments the Delish crew had to say about Rainbow Swirl and leave you with this: One staffer called it "seasoned Play-Dough." At least it's edible, right?
45Candy Bar
Halo TopAgain, Candy Bar was not a big hit with our team. We don't need to get into the gritty details—though the word "gritty" was mentioned quite a few times in passing.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
44Candy Bar (Dairy-Free)
Halo TopWhile a lot of flavors' dairy-free counterparts ranked super high on this list, Candy Bar's was not one of them. The consensus was people would just rather have candy, straight.
43Cookies & Cream
Halo TopYou go into a taste test thinking you know what Cookies & Cream tastes like...until now. Comments on Halo Top's version ranged from "weird aftertaste" to "it's floral?" Nothing inherently bad, just a bit odd.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
42Pancakes & Waffles (Dairy-Free)
Halo TopThis pretty much felt like eating straight syrup. Sure, that sounds nice in theory, but a bowl full of it is quite aggressive.
41Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Halo TopWhile the team is almost always down for a good dose of sugar, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough was a two-bites-and-you're-done type of deal.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
40Chocolate Hazelnut (Dairy-Free)
Halo Top"OMG, it's so heavy it hurts": The Chocolate Hazelnut Story.
39Mochi Green Tea
Halo TopA typically divisive flavor, it's not surprising Mochi Green Tea ended up toward the bottom of this list. I happened to love it, but the overwhelming office opinion was that it was too "perfume-y."
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
38Pancakes & Waffles
Halo TopThe pervasive syrup flavor was lessened by the dairy, one assumes, but Pancakes & Waffles was still incredibly maple-forward.
37Chocolate Mocha Chip
Halo TopThe takeaway from this pint is that low-cal ice cream does have the potential to be super rich. Like, super rich. Like, to-the-point-of-no-return rich. So rich!
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
36Caramel Macchiato
Halo TopThe main takeaway of the Caramel Macchiato flavor was its "chalkiness." The flavor was nice, the texture was solid, but it left you with a lot of chewing to do.
35Birthday Cake (Dairy-Free)
Halo TopThough the flavor was innocuous, it was so much so that there wasn't much to say about it. "Meh," one editor wrote. "It's sweet and fine," another said.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
34Gingerbread House
Halo TopMaybe it's because we've shifted our brains from Christmas flavors to Valentine's Day ones, but this pint missed the mark, in our opinion.
33Chocolate-Covered Banana
Halo TopThe overpowering banana flavor here confused a lot of people, especially because its dairy-free counterpart was one of our favs. More on that later, though.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
32Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Halo TopWhile people enjoyed the chunkiness the dough provided, they felt it hard to take more than a few bites of this flavor.
31Vanilla Bean
Halo TopEveryone liked vanilla bean. No one loved it.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
30Sea Salt Caramel
Halo TopAgain, nothing to complain about here: We'll take sea salt caramel ice cream over no sea salt caramel ice cream any day. But this version felt a little bit too salty and not enough sweet.
29Oatmeal Cookie
Halo Top"Not enough oatmeal flakes here," one oatmeal-loving staffer mentioned. As far as flavor, though? "Yum."
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
28Pistachio
Halo TopA well-rounded take on Pistachio, the staff concluded. Nothing ground-breaking, but a pleasant eating experience, for sure.
27Red Velvet
Halo TopFor as much as people were not into Gingerbread House, they were very much into Red Velvet. Why the two felt similar, no one could really identify. That said, this tasted like quality red velvet, whereas the gingerbread didn't feel all that gingerbread-like.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below