Not a chocolate fan? I got you covered. This Butterscotch Pie takes a bit of time over the stove to make, but the result of your labor is a luxuriously smooth pie filling.

Butterscotch Piepinterest
Rachel Conners

Wonder how you even make butterscotch from scratch? The flavor of butterscotch comes from brown sugar and butter; they come together similarly to the way you make pudding. You start by making a brown sugar caramel and adding milk and cream. A combination of cornstarch and egg yolks help thicken the mixture, then butter is stirred in at the end to give a rich, buttery flavor.

Butterscotch Piepinterest
Rachel Conners

I recommend straining the butterscotch filling before adding it to the pre-baked crust to make sure you get the smoothest, creamiest filling. Top the pie with a crown of whipped cream, and if have an extra few minutes, whip up some homemade butterscotch sauce to drizzle all over. You won't regret it (obviously).

butterscotch piepinterest
Rachel Conners

Get the recipe.

Follow Delish on Instagram.