Skip to Content

12 Incredible Twists on Peanut Butter Pie

You've never seen peanut butter pies like this before.
By
peanut butter pie
You've never seen peanut butter pies like this before.
1

Peanut Butter Cheesecake Pie

peanut butter cheesecake pie
Courtesy of Beyond Frosting
It's a cheesecake taken up 18 levels: An Oreo crust, with a peanut butter filling and topped with broken Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. Get the recipe at Beyond Frosting.
2

Peanut Butter Sheet Cake Pie

peanut butter sheet cake
Courtesy of Lauren's Latest
The only thing that makes peanut butter pie better is making it bigger. The crust here is actually a thin chocolate cake that's topped with all the peanut butter pie fixings. Get the recipe at Lauren's Latest.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3

Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies

peanut butter whoopie pies
Courtesy of Brooklyn Farm Girl
C'mon now: A peanut butter pie that fits in your hand? It's a win-win. Get the recipe at Brooklyn Farm Girl.
4

Peanut Butter Pudding Pie

peanut butter crumble pie
Courtesy of That's My Home
The filling here is really a light peanut butter pudding, which gives the dessert a creamy texture. (It's topped with a cookie crumble, for crunch.) Get the recipe at That's My Home.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5

Peanut Butter Twix Pie

peanut butter twix pie
Courtesy of Crazy for Crust
Peanut butter and Twix: It has a shortbread crust and a chocolate top. Take a moment to reflect. Then get the recipe at Crazy for Crust.
6

Peanut Butter Ice Cream Pie

peanut butter oreo ice cream pie
Courtesy of Kevin & Amanda
This frozen pie tastes like ice cream, but it's actually a mix of condensed milk and whipped cream—so it comes together much faster. Get the recipe at Kevin & Amanda.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Peanut Butter Silk Pie

peanut butter silk pie
Courtesy of The Gunny Sack
Wrap your head around this: A crust made of Peanut Butter Crunch Girl Scout Candy Bars, a peanut butter filling, and a topping made of more crumbled candy bars. TOO MUCH TO HANDLE. Get the recipe at The Gunny Sack.
8

Peanut Butter Pie Shooters

peanut butter pie shooters
Courtesy of Pinch of Yum
A cookie crumble bottom, and a cup full of peanut butter. It's like happiness in a shot glass. Get the recipe at Pinch of Yum.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9

Take 5 Pie

take 5 pie
Courtesy of Budget Gourmet Mom
Pretzel crust, caramel sauce, peanut butter filling, and chocolate ganache. The salty-sweet mix here might be too much goodness to handle. Get the recipe at Budget Gourmet Mom.
10

Peanut Butter Butterfinger Pie

peanut butter butterfinger pie
Courtesy of Inside Bru Crew Life
Brace yourself: A proper pie crust (store-bought, so don't sweat it), peanut butter filling, Butterfinger topping. We salute you. Get the recipe at Inside Bru Crew Life.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11

Banana Fluffernutter Pie

banana fluffernutter pie
Courtesy of Homemade Interest
Consider this our "healthy" spin on a peanut butter pie: It's topped with bananas. (Don't mind the caramel, melted chocolate, or Marshmallow Fluff.) Get the recipe at Homemade Interest.
12

Peanut Butter Pie Parfait

peanut butter parfaits
Courtesy of Hip Foodie Mom
Layers upon layers of peanut butter joy—and filled in with chocolate mousse. Pure heaven. Get the recipe at Hip Foodie Mom.
Watch Next 
preview for Meals & Cooking
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below